How to choose the right investment property as a first-time investor

8 mins
Updated
November 8, 2024

Investing in property is one of the most popular ways to build wealth, but choosing the right investment property can be overwhelming, especially for first-time investors. The real estate market offers a variety of options—each with its own set of pros and cons. From capital growth potential to rental demand, and deciding between residential or commercial properties, detached homes or apartments, or new builds versus established homes, several factors need to be carefully considered. In this article, we’ll explore the key aspects that can help guide you in making the right investment decision.

Capital growth

Capital growth refers to the increase in the value of a property over time, which is a crucial consideration for long-term investors looking to build wealth. The potential for capital growth depends on various factors like location, infrastructure development, and economic trends.

  • Location is key: Properties located in areas with strong economic activity, good transport links, and ongoing infrastructure development tend to appreciate faster. Suburbs near employment hubs, shopping centers, schools, and public transport are often good bets for capital growth.
  • Supply and demand: Limited supply in a high-demand area typically leads to property price increases. Research the supply pipeline in the area—if there’s an oversupply of new developments, it might reduce potential capital growth.
  • Gentrification: Investing in an area undergoing urban renewal or gentrification can offer excellent capital growth prospects, as property values in such areas usually increase as the neighborhood improves.

First-time investors looking for strong capital growth should focus on markets with upward trends in property values, rather than focusing solely on short-term rental yields.

Rental demand

Rental demand is another crucial factor, particularly for investors looking to generate steady income from their investment property. Properties in areas with high rental demand can provide a consistent cash flow, helping cover mortgage payments, maintenance, and other expenses.

  • Employment opportunities: Properties close to business districts or areas with job growth tend to attract renters. People want to live near where they work, making these locations desirable for tenants.
  • Lifestyle amenities: Renters often prioritize proximity to cafes, restaurants, shopping centers, and recreational spaces. Properties near universities, schools, and public transport also tend to have high rental demand.
  • Vacancy rates: Look for areas with low vacancy rates, as this indicates strong demand for rental properties. High vacancy rates might signal an oversupply or lack of renter interest, which could hurt your cash flow.

First-time investors should aim for properties in areas with stable rental markets to ensure a steady income and lower the risk of long-term vacancies.

Residential vs commercial properties

When choosing an investment property, one of the primary decisions is between residential and commercial real estate. Each has distinct advantages and disadvantages, and the right choice will depend on your risk tolerance, capital, and investment goals.

Residential properties

A residential property is a type of real estate that is primarily used for living purposes. It includes houses, apartments, townhouses, and other dwellings where individuals or families reside. 

Pros:

  • Easier to understand and access, especially for first-time investors.
  • Strong demand for housing, ensuring rental opportunities in most areas.
  • Fewer barriers to entry, with lower upfront costs compared to commercial properties.

Cons:

  • Lower rental yields compared to commercial properties.
  • Tenancy turnover can be more frequent, resulting in higher management costs.

Commercial properties

Pros:

  • Higher rental yields, often around 6–10%, compared to residential properties.
  • Longer leases, providing more stability and fewer management headaches.

Cons:

  • More significant upfront investment and higher risk, especially during economic downturns.
  • More complex to manage and requires a deeper understanding of the commercial market.

For first-time investors, residential properties are often the safer and simpler choice, as they typically have lower risks and provide steady returns. Commercial properties can offer higher yields, but they come with more complexity and risk.

Detached housing vs apartments

Deciding between detached houses and apartments is another key consideration when selecting your investment property. Both types have their unique benefits and drawbacks.

Detached Houses

Pros:

  • Greater capital growth potential due to land value.
  • Typically more attractive to families, who often stay longer as tenants, reducing turnover.
  • More space and privacy, making them desirable to a broad range of tenants.

Cons:

  • Higher maintenance costs, as the entire property (inside and out) is your responsibility.
  • Higher upfront costs compared to apartments.

Apartments

Pros:

  • Lower entry price, making them more accessible for first-time investors.
  • Often located in inner-city or high-demand rental areas, ensuring strong rental returns.
  • Less maintenance responsibility, as common areas are managed by the body corporate.

Cons:

  • Less land value, limiting capital growth potential.
  • Subject to body corporate fees and regulations, which can reduce your net returns.
  • Tenants may be less stable, leading to higher turnover.

First-time investors should weigh the pros and cons based on their budget, long-term goals, and target tenant market. Detached homes may offer better long-term growth, while apartments can provide more affordable entry points and steady rental demand in urban areas.

New builds vs established homes

Lastly, deciding between new builds and established homes is an important consideration. Both offer distinct advantages and challenges.

New builds

A new build is a property that has been recently constructed and has never been lived in. New builds often feature modern designs, up-to-date fixtures, and the latest building standards. 

Pros:

  • Lower maintenance costs and fewer repairs in the first few years.
  • Modern features that attract tenants, especially in competitive rental markets.
  • Often come with warranties, providing added security for investors.

Cons:

  • Higher upfront price, with a premium for "brand-new" properties.
  • Potentially limited capital growth in the short term, as new properties tend to appreciate more slowly initially.
  • Located in new developments, which may lack established infrastructure or community services.

Established homes

An established home refers to a property that has been previously owned and occupied. These homes are typically located in more mature, developed neighborhoods with established infrastructure. 

Pros:

  • Often located in well-established neighborhoods with high capital growth potential.
  • More room for negotiation on price, and potential to add value through renovations.
  • Historical data available on property performance and market trends in the area.

Cons:

  • Higher maintenance costs, as older homes may require repairs and upgrades.
  • Less modern features, which can make it harder to attract high-paying tenants.

For first-time investors, established homes in growth areas can offer immediate rental returns and capital appreciation opportunities, while new builds provide peace of mind with lower maintenance and modern appeal.

Choosing the right investment property as a first-time investor involves balancing several critical factors—capital growth potential, rental demand, property type, and whether to buy new or established. By understanding these dynamics and aligning them with your financial goals, you can make a more informed decision that maximizes returns while managing risks. Whether you're looking for immediate rental income, long-term capital growth, or a mix of both, thoughtful planning and market research are essential steps on your property investment journey.

Disclaimer
Prepared by Beck McLean Finance Pty Ltd ABN 80 632 809 833. This information does not take your personal objectives, circumstances or needs into account. Always read the disclosure documents for products and services before deciding on a product or service, and consider seeking independent legal, financial, taxation or other advice for your unique circumstances.
continue reading

Found that helpful?
There's more just like that.